Aquaphor or Vaseline. Don't overthink it.

Aquaphor or plain petroleum jelly is your best bet for preventing eyelid chapping in bitter cold.

Eyelids are thin, have almost no oil glands, and take a beating from wind, dry air, and mask friction. Fancy eye creams with peptides or hyaluronic acid won’t cut it — they’re designed for hydration and wrinkles, not barrier protection. What you need is an occlusive that physically seals the skin against moisture loss.

Aquaphor is my go-to because it contains lanolin, which helps repair cracks, and petrolatum for the seal. If you’re allergic to lanolin