Coach leather crossbody bags outlast the others.

Coach, by a fair margin.

All three brands make solid bags at this price point (~$200–$500), but Coach consistently uses thicker, higher-quality leather and better stitching. Michael Kors leans heavier on coated canvas and thinner leather that shows wear faster. Tory Burch is closer to Coach in design but often uses softer, less durable leather that scuffs and loses shape quicker.

If you want a bag that still looks good in five years, get the Coach. If you want something trendier for a season or two, MK or Tory Burch will do fine. Just don’t expect them to hold up the same way.