Stick to the central lawn behind the visitor center.

Yes. The safest spot on Goat Island for toddlers is the open grassy area behind the main visitor center. It has low fences, no drop-offs, and plenty of space to run.

The overlooks at Terrapin Point and Luna Island have railings but still have steep drops right behind them – a determined toddler could squeeze through or climb on benches. The Three Sisters Islands bridges have gaps between railings that a small kid could slip through. The lawn near the snack bar and restrooms is your best bet: it’s fenced, flat, and far from the gorge.

If you need a view, carry the kid to the edge, hold them tight, and move on. This is not the place to let them explore on their own.