The SM57 is the cheap secret to intimate vocals.
Yes, get a Shure SM57. It’s the boring answer, but boring is good when you’re on a budget and chasing that close-up, present sound.
Julia Jacklin’s vocals feel like she’s right there in the room because she often uses a dynamic microphone (like an SM7B) that lets her get close without the harshness or room echo that cheap condensers pick up. The SM57 is basically the little brother of the SM7B. Same capsule design, just less built-in Presence boost. You can dial that in with EQ.
Why not a budget condenser